Grub Showdown: Black Soldier Fly Larvae vs Mealworms

When it comes to treating your backyard flock to a protein-packed snack, the battle between black soldier fly larvae vs mealworms is on! In one corner, we have the heavyweight champion of sustainability, the Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL). In the other, the classic crowd favorite, Mealworms. Both are beloved by chickens far and wide, but which one really rules the roost? Let’s dig in (or should we say, peck in?) to this showdown and find out who earns the title of Ultimate Chicken Snack!

Round 1: Nutritional Knockout

Chickens love their treats, but it’s not just about what tastes good, it’s about what fuels their little feathered bodies for egg-laying, foraging, and general mischief.

Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL):

• Protein — Approximately 30–53% of dry matter, depending on factors like diet and growth conditions.

• Fat — Ranges from 20–41% of dry matter, influenced by the larvae's diet and developmental stage.

• Calcium — High levels, around 35 g/kg on a dry matter basis.

• Other Benefits — Rich in minerals, vitamins, iron, magnesium, sodium, zinc, potassium, and amino acids.

Mealworms:

• Protein — Approximately 20–50% of dry matter, varying based on rearing substrates and environmental conditions.

• Fat — Around 22.3% to 39.5% on a dry matter basis.

• Calcium — Low levels, around 2.7–7.4 g/kg on a dry matter basis.

• Other Benefits — Contains essential minerals such as protein, fiber, essential fats, vitamins, and minerals.

Winner: If you're after sustainability, calcium-rich snacks for stronger eggshells, and a nutrient-packed buffet of minerals and amino acids, Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL) clearly rule the roost. For a tasty, high-protein snack that boosts feather regrowth and muscle strength, especially helpful during molting, Mealworms hold their own.

(Pssst… Speaking of egg-laying powerhouses, don’t forget to give your hens an extra boost with our Herb Supplement for Backyard Chickens, packed with natural nutrients to keep them happy, healthy, and laying!)

Round 2: Black Soldier Fly Larvae VS Mealworms Sustainability Smackdown

We all love our chickens, but let’s talk about what’s best for the planet too.

Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL):

• They’re nature’s cleanup crew! BSFL gobble up food scraps, farm waste, and even manure, drastically cutting landfill waste.

• BSFL farms are lean, green, and efficient, using minimal water and land compared to traditional livestock (and even mealworms!).

• These larvae produce fewer greenhouse gases, giving chickens (and the planet!) something to cluck happily about.

• Lightning-fast growers, they mature in just two weeks, perfect for impatient hens who can’t wait for snack time!

Mealworms:

• Traditionally, mealworms feast on grain-based diets, which tap into our agricultural resources. However, they're not too picky and can thrive on by-products from food industries, potentially lightening their environmental footprint. ​

• Compared to traditional livestock, mealworm farming is a green dream, sipping less water and occupying minimal land. But, they do enjoy a comfy, climate-controlled environment, which might nudge up energy use. ​

• Mealworms are eco-champions, producing fewer greenhouse gases than cattle or pigs. However, Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL) might edge them out slightly in the waste-reduction arena. ​

• Patience is a little bit needed with mealworms; they take about 3 to 30 days to reach their full, snack-worthy potential.

Winner: BSFL by a landslide! These little wrigglers are eco-friendly powerhouses, turning waste into nutrient-dense food for your flock while keeping things sustainable.

Round 3: Taste Test (A.K.A. The Hen’s Vote)

When it comes to snack time, chickens aren’t exactly known for their refined palates. If it moves, crunches, or even slightly resembles food, chances are they’ll give it a peck. Both Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL) and mealworms are a hit in the coop, with most chickens happily gobbling them up without a second thought. But if we’re getting picky (unlike our hens), there are a few subtle differences in preference.

Some chickens enjoy the extra crunch factor of mealworms, making them the perfect little crispy snack. On the other hand, BSFL are meatier and juicier, which some birds find irresistible. It’s kind of like choosing between chips and a protein-packed snack, both are tasty, but the textures and flavors offer a slightly different experience.

Winner: At the end of the day, this taste test ends in a tie. Whether your hens are on Team Crunchy or Team Juicy, both BSFL and mealworms are sure to be devoured in record time. Because let’s be real, chickens will eat just about anything (and everything) with enthusiasm!

(While you’re at it, give your flock an extra boost with AquaBoost—our water supplement for backyard chickens, formulated with vitamins and electrolytes for overall hydration and health!)

Final Verdict: Which Should You Pick?

When it comes to choosing the perfect treat for your flock, Black Soldier Fly Larvae (BSFL) emerge as the champions of sustainability and nutrition. Packed with up to 50 times more calcium than mealworms, BSFL plays a pivotal role in strengthening eggshells and supporting overall health. Their eco-friendly nature and nutrient-rich profile make them an excellent choice for enhancing your hens' diet. 

Adding GrubFuel – Black Soldier Fly Larvae to your flock’s routine is an easy way to ensure they get all the calcium and protein they need for top-notch egg production. With every peck, your hens are getting a natural boost for stronger shells and happier, healthier days. A treat that’s good for them and the planet? Now that’s something worth clucking about!

However, mealworms shouldn't be dismissed, as they offer a high protein content beneficial for molting birds and muscle development. To provide a well-rounded diet, consider offering a mix of BSFL and mealworms, ensuring your hens receive a variety of nutrients and flavors.​

Remember, while these insect treats are nutritious, they should complement a balanced diet. Incorporating products like CoopShield—Diatomaceous Earth and Herbs for Chickens can further enhance your flock's environment by repelling pests and maintaining a clean, cozy coop.

Want more tips, tricks, and cluckin’ good content? Follow us on Facebook and keep those chickens living their best life!